4 Breweries Putting Goshen on the Map

*Originally published Oct. 2015, for the updated version of this story click here https://goodofgoshen.com/project/great-breweries-near-goshen/.

5 Breweries Putting Goshen on the Map
Thirsty for something … different? You’ve come to the right place.

Goshen is home to a number of breweries offering delicious selections of beer and coffee. Here’s a list of Goshen’s five local brewing establishments where you can enjoy a tasty beverage in the Maple City.

Drink the coffee electric

The Electric Brew

118 East Washington Street

The Electric Brew is a relaxing downtown gathering place where return customers can be found morning to evening. The Brew also enjoys the distinction of being Goshen’s first-ever coffeehouse.

Brenda Hostetler-Kauffman and Tony Kauffman opened The Electric Brew on April 4, 1996, at 136 S. Main St. The store served gourmet coffees, espresso drinks, and baked items. Brew offerings quickly expanded to include a lunch menu, blended drinks and additional baked goods.

Brenda and Tony sold The Electric Brew in May 2007. The coffeehouse, which has since moved to East Washington Street, is now owned by Myron and Dana Bontrager and their sons, Jeremy and Christopher.

“ … A number of years before we bought The Brew, we fell in love with downtown Goshen,” Myron said. “I had come to know a number of business owners, employees, and in general those who were certainly passionate about making Goshen something even more special than it already was. The more I got to know the downtown, the more I wanted to be a part of what was happening.”

Myron added that even though his family is passionate about coffee, “it is the people that we have gotten to know over the past eight years that have made it so worthwhile for us. We have learned to know so many great people that make Goshen, and specifically the downtown, a really great place to live and own a business.”

The Electric Brew began roasting the coffee in-house in August 2008. In September 2008, The Brew became certified as a Fair Trade Certified coffeehouse.

Like that cup of coffee you just had at The Electric Brew? The store’s coffee beans are always available for purchase.

Handcrafted, locally drafted, and absolutely delicious

Goshen Brewing Co.

315 West Washington Street

Goshen Brewing Co. (more affectionately known by fans as “GBCo.”) is in a repurposed public service building two blocks off Main Street, sitting along the Elkhart River.

Jesse and Amanda Sensenig are the founders of the family-friendly brewpub. The Sensenigs’ zest for beer, food, and community was developed while living in Charleston, S.C., and later in Fort Collins, Colo. Fort Collins at that time boasted the most breweries per capita in the United States. The Sensenigs checked them out, and Jesse began brewing and developing recipes.

Amanda is a Goshen native, and both she and Jesse are Goshen College graduates. They kept returning to Goshen, and fell in love with it.

“We wanted to move back this way,” said Jesse, who’s originally from Archbold, Ohio. “We felt like Goshen was a place we could see ourselves and thought it was a good place for a brewery. This building came up as an option right at the beginning. That kind of pushed us to put together a business plan and make it a reality.”

More hungry than thirsty? The menu at Goshen Brewing Co. features a range of food offerings, with an emphasis on organic and locally produced ingredients. While you’re dining, you can look through a glass-paned window into GBCo’s on-site seven-barrel brewhouse.

Here’s a place that’s right up your alley

Back Alley Brewery

211 ½ South Main Street

The aptly named Back Alley Brewery has been in business since September 2013. It’s located next to the alley between South Main and 3rd Street and shares an entry with Art House, an indie film theater.

Back Alley Brewery is connected to another Goshen favorite, Gateway Cellar Winery. Working with an importer from Georgia, the winery owners get grapes from around the world to produce the many varieties of wine available at the downtown business.

Back Alley co-owner Larry Libey said the winery was purchased four years ago, and the idea was to open the bar three or four years after that. However, the rear-building space that is now home to Back Alley became available, so the brewery plans were put on a faster track.

“We have six different beers on tap that we make,” Libey said. Back Alley customers can also carry out the craft beer of their choosing in a growler.

Small batches, big taste

Thomas-Stieglitz Brewing Co.

211 South Fifth Street

Thomas-Stieglitz Brewing Co. is the newest downtown Goshen brewery.

Thomas-Stieglitz Brewing Co. is a production brewery, and has growler sales available to the public. The owners also distribute beer to local restaurants and taverns. They also do glass pours for customers who want to stop in and enjoy a beer on site.

“Being a small-batch operation, we are able try and introduce new things all the time,” Stieglitz said.



Good of Goshen Photography • Lynne Zehr, Grant Beachy
Good of Goshen Editor • Scott Weisser

Do you have a story you want to tell?

Do you have a story to tell about someone who contributes to Goshen’s greater GOOD?

We invite you to share!