9 Mind-Blowingly Good Taquerias in Goshen

9 Mind-Blowingly Good Taquerias in Goshen • The Good of Goshen

The Maple City is home to people from nearly every continent, but one of the largest cultural representation is Latin American. Thirty percent of Goshen’s population hails from Mexico – from Chihuahua in northern Mexico to Oaxaca in the south, and everywhere in between.

With such a wide cultural representation (from within Mexico alone!), it’s no surprise that Goshen has an abundance of mouthwatering Mexican restaurants. Here’s our list of nine local taquerias that are so good (and 100 percent authentic), you’ll feel as if you’re south of the border.

Los Primos

122 East Clinton Street, and 
124 West Jefferson Street

With two downtown locations, a catering business, and food truck, Los Primos is one of Goshen’s largest Mexican dining establishments. This family-owned business specializes in a wide variety of dishes – everything from Mexican-style soup and sandwiches to gigantic burritos and spicy, piping-hot fajitas – but they’re most famous for their fried plantains and fish tacos.

Chef Lopez and his delicious recipes keep this taqueria around the clock. Stop in for lunch or dinner any day of the week except Wednesday for some amazing and oh-so authentic Mexican food.

Los Primos

Photo by Lynne Zehr

Taqueria San Jose

613 East Madison Street

Taqueria San Jose has some of the best tacos in town. They are served piping hot and piled high with fresh ingredients including cilantro, onion, and avocado, and are full of tender, flavorful meat (vegetarian options are available, too!).

Top off your meal with an ice-cold Jarritos soda and a fresh baked good from their bakery case. 

Taqueria San Jose

Photo from Yelp

Taqueria El Maza

214 Johnson Street

Taqueria El Maza is one of Goshen’s newest taquerias, but it’s quickly gaining popularity among locals.

The menu includes Mexican staples like fajitas, burritos, and chimichangas, but also includes a number of unique items including a Mexican shrimp cocktail, or shrimp in tomato sauce topped with avocados. 

Taqueria El Maza

Photo from Facebook

San Marcos

113 South Main Street

San Marcos, located in the heart of downtown Goshen, is a mom-and-pop restaurant known for its fresh, flavorful dishes. Their tacos are made with fresh cilantro and onion, juicy and flavorful meat or beans, and a few limes on the side for extra zest.

Of course, you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, especially when you smother it with a healthy dose of their house-made salsa and guacamole.

San Marcos, Goshen, Indiana

Photo by Grant Beachy

El Duranguenze

113 West Washington Street

El Duranguenze (or “of Durango, Mexico”) has been family-owned and operated since 2007. When you step inside their cozy and festive downtown location, you’ll feel as if you’ve been transported straight to Durango. Once you taste the dishes, you’ll never be able to go back to fast-food Tex-Mex again!

Many of their ingredients, like spices and beans, are imported directly from Mexico, making them truly auténtico.

El Duranguenze, Goshen, Indiana

Photo by Grant Beachy

Tacos El Portal

428 West Pike Street

Tacos El Portal is one of Goshen’s only permanent food trucks. The truck is located along Pike Street in Goshen, just north of downtown. Whether you stop by over your lunch break or for a late-night snack, Tacos El Portal delivers some of the best authentic Mexican food you’ll ever taste.

They’re well known for their steak tacos, but we mean it when we say that there is no second best on this menu. Try it all, then try it all again.

Tacos El Portal, Goshen, Indiana

Photo from Facebook

Universal Tamal

225 South Main Street

Universal Tamal in downtown Goshen is best known for – yep, you guessed it! – tamales! If you haven’t tried this Meso-American comfort food before, you’re missing out. Tamales are a traditional Mexican dish made with masa, meat, spices, and vegetables steamed in a corn husk. When you unwrap the husk, you’re in for a fabulously flavorful and filling delight.

When you visit, try the sweet tamales, which are reminiscent of the flavor of horchata. 

Universal Tamal, Goshen, Indiana

Photo from Yelp

Restaurante Familiar San Jose

2124 Elkhart Road

Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner every day except Monday, Restaurante San Jose is a fantastic restaurant to sit down for an authentic Mexican meal whenever hunger strikes. Whatever you order, we recommend completing your meal with a tall glass of sweet, spicy, and oh-so cinnamon-y horchata.

The restaurant is located next door to a Mexican grocery store and butcher shop, Carniceria San Jose, where you can pick up ingredients to re-create your own authentic Mexican meal at home! 

Photo from Yelp

El Camino Real #4

427 West Pike Street

El Camino Real #4 was one of the first Mexican restaurants in Goshen, and has remained one of the most dearly loved. With its spacious interior, El Camino is a great place to sit down with a large group of friends and family. You’re sure to find your favorite dish on its expansive menu, but we recommend trying the burrito, which is full of rice, beans, vegetables, and meat of your choice. Put an extra kick in your dinner with one of their famous margaritas or daiquiris!

Photo from Yelp

Hope you’re hungry! Remember, this list covers only a small selection of the authentic local Mexican restaurants in Goshen. If you’d like to get the word out about a taqueria that isn’t mentioned, we invite you to submit your own story. Click here to learn more!

Good of Goshen Editor • Liz Core

Do you have a story you want to tell?

Do you have a story to tell about someone who contributes to Goshen’s greater GOOD?

We invite you to share!

Share this story!