Goshen’s Hundred-Year-Old Icon

Olympia Candy Kitchen • Good of Goshen

Published Nov. 2016

Olympia Candy Kitchen • Good of Goshen • photo credit: Grant Beachy
One hundred and four years ago, a little soda shop was started on the corner of Main and Clinton. One Great Depression, two world wars, 18 presidents, 12 Americans on the moon — and that same soda shop is still going.

“We’ve survived a lot of things,” said Olympia Candy Kitchen’s owner Kare Andersen. “And we’re still going strong.”

In 1912, Olympia Candy Kitchen was started by Sam Husaus. Eight years later, Greek immigrant Nicholas Paflas bought the restaurant with his wife Leona. Ninety six years later, the family business is in its fourth generation, safely in the hands of great-grandson of the Paflas, Kare Anderson.

“We’ve withstood the test of time,” said Kare. “With hard work, dedication, and keeping up the building — that’s how we’ve lasted so long.”

Kare explained that Olympia started out primarily as a candy store and ice cream parlor, and “food options grew and grew as time went on.”

Menu items started out as simple sandwiches, then burgers, and over time, they developed a full lunch menu. When Kare’s mom ran Olympia, she added breakfast.

Lunch offerings have changed over the years, as have the candy options.

“It’s evolved a lot,” said Kare. “In my term, dark chocolate has become very popular. You just have to change with the times.”

Despite the little changes, Olympia continues the tradition of, according to Kare, “good product, friendly customer service, and good food.”

Olympia makes many of its products in-house, including caramels, toffee, mayonnaise, vegetable soup, and flavored syrups. They’ve been adding homemade syrups to their soda from the beginning, when soda was made in-shop by combining carbonated water with flavored sugar syrups.

“I like to say that we had cherry Coke before Coke did,” Kare laughed.

Homemade food and cherry Coke are just a few things that have set Olympia Candy Kitchen apart. Unique items like the olive nut sandwich, along with homemade, hand-dipped chocolate, make it unique.

“We’re not just a restaurant, we’re not just a candy store,” Kare said. “We’re both.”

In addition to maintaining their original atmosphere and values, much of the physical space is still the same as it was back in 1912.

“We try to keep the building the same as much as possible,” Kare said. “The ceiling, the light fixtures, even some of the booths are original.”

The location of Olympia has helped keep it running for so long. In the past, it has been a prime spot for tourists, locals, courthouse officials, and even visiting politicians and former presidents.

The food, the building, and the location certainly set Olympia apart, but they aren’t the key to what’s made it iconic.

“This place is such an icon because of the loyal customers,’” Kare said.

Olympia Candy Kitchen

136 North Main Street,
Goshen, Indiana

Monday 7 a.m. – 5 p.m.
Tuesday 7 a.m. – 5 p.m.
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 7 a.m. – 5 p.m.
Friday 7 a.m. – 5 p.m.
Saturday 7 a.m. – 3 p.m.
Sunday 9 a.m. – 1 p.m.

(574) 533-5040

Just as the owners have passed Olympia down through their family, customers have shared the tradition of going with their children and grandchildren. Kare’s grandparents knew the grandparents of many of the current loyal customers.

“I love hearing those stories,” said Kare. “People will come in here now who are grandparents who came in here with their grandparents. It’s cool to see generations of regulars. I know a lot of loyal customers by their first name or what they eat.”

Customers come to Olympia for food, chocolate, and the old-fashioned atmosphere.

“People enjoy coming here because it is nostalgic,” Kare said. “It reminds them of the way it was when everything moved a little slower.”

Kare admitted he’s thought about trying to open another place as good as Olympia, but he admitted, “You can’t recreate this atmosphere. You can’t recreate what we have.”

While Kare is happy with just one Olympia, he does want to expand the business in other ways.

“There are ways of expanding without opening other businesses,” said Kare. “We grow from within.”

Kare explained that Olympia is growing by increasing sales across the country. Olympia ships chocolate to customers across the United States.

Kare never expected that owning Olympia would become a central part of his life.

Kare started his relationship with Olympia in high school. He worked there while his parents were running the business, but soon realized he needed more experience. So, Kare got a job at Olive Garden.

He went to college, married, and had four kids. He moved around living in both California and Arizona. Twelve years ago, Kare decided to come back.

“I never thought I would come back here,” admitted Kare. “I thought I would get a job and live elsewhere. I did for a while, but then you start realizing what’s important in life, and family is most important.”

Kare expected to just come back home to live, not to run the business. His parents never pressured Kare to run the business, but he started running it out of necessity.

“I didn’t come back with the intention of working here,” Kare said. “But my mom needed help, so I started working, helping out, and I never left.”

Kare said that running Olympia is hard work.

“Olympia Candy Kitchen has defined who I am,” he said. “Running this place, having employees, and talking with people every day makes you look at life a little differently.”

Running Olympia impacts Kare’s involvement the community, too.

“Because I work here, I try to stay involved,” Kare said. “I’m in a committee of local downtown businesses that maintains flower beds and clears snow for the downtown. We try to keep things looking nice. What’s good for Goshen is good for us.”

Kare wants to see Olympia remain the icon it is today.

“I hope we are still open another 100 years,” he said.

Author Bio

Grace Bickel and Elizabeth Rieth, both seniors at Goshen High School, are leading members of the GHS student newspaper, The Talon. This year, Grace and Elizabeth are enrolled in a self-led independent study in journalism, where they are branching out from the high school audience and writing about the larger Goshen community. Growing up in such a vibrant community has fostered a love for Goshen. They’ve partnered with the Good of Goshen to write stories about unique local businesses and their history.

Elizabeth Rieth

Elizabeth Rieth, a senior at Goshen High School, spends her time involved in marching band, Crimsonaires, and as the editor-in-chief of The Talon. This past summer, she interned at the Elkhart Truth. In her leisure time, she enjoys kayaking, reading and spending time with her Golden Lab, Daisy. Whether it’s the dam pond, the downtown theatre or the steak tacos at San Marcos, Elizabeth can’t get enough of Goshen. After high school, Elizabeth plans to pursue journalism at an undecided school.

The Talon
Read more on The Talon site.
Story by Elizabeth Rieth
Photography by Grace Bickel and Grant Beachy
Good of Goshen Editor • Liz Shenk

Do you have a story you want to tell?

Do you have a story to tell about someone who contributes to Goshen’s greater GOOD?

We invite you to share!